FILM REVIEW: THE LULLABY
25/9/2018
BY JOE X YOUNGLullaby. A film which doesn’t need one.
1901, Reitfontein concentration camp, a baby is murdered, its neck is broken and it is thrown off a cliff. In a voiceover… “If one of us fell pregnant, the Priest and the Midwife would make certain that the baby would never see a sunrise” The scene is of white people in clean clothes holding back the mother whilst the Priest gives the usual bullshit about sin, and then the baby gets killed and dumped. I’m surprised that they chose that to begin a film with as at the Reitfontein Camp the death of children was a daily thing with many months seeing child mortality rates in the hundreds, sometimes going into thousands. Disease, malnutrition, exposure, lack of medical care and various other causes resulted in around a third of the population dying, with children representing 81% of the deaths at the ‘Black camps’. There’s enough horror there without having to invent any. Cut to modern day, a delivery room and a woman in labour. Chloe (Reine Swart) has the baby and rejects it. Her estranged mom Ruby (Thandi Puren) takes charge in spite of being pissed off that her daughter won’t say who the father is, and is seemingly incapable of doing even the most basic things new mothers should do such as clipping the baby’s nails, using a breast milk pump et cetera. She is (and looks) totally exhausted because the baby never stops crying. It’s all stuff we’ve seen before a dozen times, and there’s actually nothing new to see here. I think a big warning regarding this film is that it comes from the same director as ‘Dracula 3000’, so yeah, it ain’t good. The acting is good, never quite good enough to elevate the mundane plot, but certainly not among the worst. It does give a bunch of scares, however they are mostly jump-scares and I’m probably not alone in thinking that they are generally present at the expense of actual proper scares which require a depth to them that this film fails to adequately convey. Think back to the beginning, and to an actual horror which really happened. Surely with Reitfontein as the basis for the fictitious intro there could have been such a lot of ties to it throughout, but there wasn’t. No ‘angry spirits rising en-masse’, just a bunch of hallucinations about an evil old woman who wants Chloe to kill the baby. The Lullaby isn’t dire. It’s watchable, but it is nothing new. Currently available as VOD. HORROR FILM REVIEW: STILL/BORN
20/9/2018
by joe x young
There are many films covering the cliché of spooky goings-on mixed with postpartum depression and Still/Born does little to push any boundaries. It’s a routine tale of Mary (Christie Burke) who is pregnant with twins but loses one during childbirth. Her depression supposedly manifests in the form of a Demon and the film hangs heavily on Mary’s anxiety over potentially losing the surviving child, which to pile on the clichés is called ‘Adam’. Another cliché is the somewhat witless husband Jack (Jesse Moss) who comes across as being as useful as a chocolate fireguard.
I don’t know if it’s my testosterone levels interfering with my enjoyment here but I just don’t find this sort of film to be delivering the goods to any great degree and I think it’s probably the case that I’m not the intended audience for this film. However, horror is horror and as such it should be effective no matter who is watching it, in this case it is lacking the fundamental ability to grip my interest. The audio-visual ‘hallucinations’ that Mary has are meant to be disturbing, but mostly are just contrived jump-scares which don’t do anything for me these days as I’ve seen too many of them to be impressed and would much prefer some actual atmosphere. This is not to say that there’s no atmosphere in this film, just that what there is of it is lumbering and isn’t served well by yet another ‘demon’ which looks like a grotty mental patient with all of the jerkiness used to better effect in the ‘Judderman’ Metz commercials which were far scarier than this film. Mary is a believable character, with Christie Burke giving a solid performance which through the fluctuations of the plot shows enough versatility, it’s just a shame that her obvious acting talent is wasted on such a pedestrian film. It’s a grind, nothing much happens in the first half of the film, with the possibility of something demonic going on only happening toward the half-way stage with a broken window and a demonic voice (Am I the only one who is tired of ‘demonic voices’ sounding like Gollum with a forty-a-day smoking habit?). There are no real noteworthy performances other than Christie’s with the possible exception of Michael Ironside’s brief appearances as Mary’s therapist, he’s always good value no matter what and is grossly underused in this. There’s a minimalistic stab at atmosphere here, and it all seems so damned familiar. The technical aspects are fine, sound and lighting add to the mood as it would be expected but there are certain aspects which are truly annoying, such as the reliance on a crying baby for creepy atmosphere and of course the aforementioned rasping ‘Demon’ voice. Baby monitors, webcams and sticking doors are used to assist with the delivery of tension which again doesn’t quite work as it’s all been done before and often better, and of course the cameras showing a totally different take on what actually happened, which is all anti-climactic in a horror story. The last fifteen minutes unravel in plot and in Mary’s sanity; it’s all a bit of a mess of improbable scenarios leading to an ending which is meant to be terrifying but just comes across as preposterous. If you have seen ‘The Babadook’ or ‘Mama’ then you have seen films which are much better than Still/Born and if you really want to see something along this line but much better then seek out the original ‘Rosemary’s Baby’. HORROR NEWS: FRIGHTFEST PRESENTS THE DARK ON DVD AND DIGITAL 22 OCT
|
Archives
April 2023
|