REALLY? COME ON THIS IS JUST WRONG!
21/5/2014
I've been mulling over whether or not to write this post for a couple of weeks. And to be honest even as I am writing it I'm wondering if I should name the website that really got up my nose. I'm still not sure, but as this is another we'll just have to wait and see if I spill all the beans. Before getting to the nitty gritty of this post, I first want to say that I fully understand that websites, and in particular ones that have a great deal of new content, want to make a bit of money, time is money of course. However there are ways and means of doing this. ones that don't just smell of wrongness. So what has got my goat up? A couple of weeks ago I came across this via a link on twitter "For a reasonable fee of £20, I will feature your book on my blog, interview you all about your book and share on my extensive social media networks. PLUS: I’ll email you a cool badge for your own blog. This lets your own readers know your book has been featured on this popular blog." This really really got my back, not because I thought "hey I've missed a trick", but because in my honest opinion this is just wrong on so many levels. This just smells of the same shit that paying review sites for a review. As soon as money becomes directly involved with a service all sense of objectivity is lost. By accepting payment the owner of this site is now obliged to post the interview and promote your book regardless of the quality of the book or even the interview. I as an interviewer take great pride in my interviews, they are done out of passion, the thought of charging any money for the interview just makes me feel sick. Interviews should be free, a good quality interview will drive traffic to your site, and spread the word of he author. Use this along with adverts on your site and links to Amazon to generate sales. I've had a look at their interviews, and for £20, I would expect a hell of a lot more than some generic Q and A that show no originality or thought. The ones I read made me weep. I sweat blood and tears over my interviews, hell I was up at 4am this morning just trying to get an interview written before the kids got up. I also feel that if you are going to charge for this service your site better look professional, and not like the kindergarten mess that the site looks like. Pastel colours, comic sans fonts, and cutesy graphics that even the most girly of girls would cringe at do not make for a professional looking site. There is also another part of this, this site is wanting you the author to pay for the privilege of filling in a generic interview that will be read by 12,000 followers, but you also get a cool badge to put on your site. A COOL BADGE, wait a minute! Back it up a little bit. I not only have to pay for the interview, but you also expect me to then advertise your site on mine with one of your cutesy artsy crafty badges. I don't think so. You want me to pay you to advertise your site, do I look stupid? You make it sound as though the badge is a cool thing, it's not. I stopped wearing badges when I left school. And I sure as hell won't be adding your badge to my site? "Many blogs will ‘feature’ your book with a link to Amazon, which is fabulous, but I believe it is important to give readers a real incentive to buy your book and not just ‘sponsor’ a book for a fee." Damn right, many blogs will feature your book with links to Amazon, but what they won't do is charge you for the privilege. Stop making it out to sound as though your hard earned £20 is suddenly going to get you more readers. This site is not doing you any favours at all, none whatsoever. All it is doing is making her money.
If you are that desperate I could give you a list of dozens of sites that will do this for free, you do not need to pay for this. The site also states that they are interested in any genre. I'll let you in on a big secret, 99% of book readers won't pick up a book that is outside of their preferred genre. Especially when it comes to non horror readers, that's why there are no horror books or urban fantasy, and very little fantasy and science fiction on the bookshelves of supermarkets. The readership of this site will most likely not be interested in your book. If that's the case you may as well just piss the money down the drain. No I realise that this may sound like sour grapes, it's not I can assure you of that, this is coming from my love of the genre, and I hate to see people getting ripped off. It makes me angry, even angrier than review sites who refuse to cross post onto places like Amazon and Goodreads, but that's a rant for next week.
Paul Flewitt
21/5/2014 04:46:17
Agreed wholeheartedly with this. I don't have many reviews on my book, but the ones I do have are from honest people who actually read the thing! I think I ssid before; I'd frame a Jim Mcleod review of my work, even if you ripped it to shreds, simply because you review and comment honestly as a fan of the genre. That's priceless.
I think the situation is worse than you state here, Jim - I feel such sites are actually no better than con-artists, fleecing inexperienced indie writers out of money. The reason I say that is simple - 'stats' notwithstanding, no remotely discerning reader is going to trust a site with this kind of paid content - they will assume, correctly, that material bought and paid for this way has no integrity at all. Therefore, not only will they not trust what they read, they are likely to actively avoid authors that use such services, because they know that author is 'paying' for good coverage - this could mean that even legitimate positive reviews on Amazon etc. are viewed with suspicion. 21/5/2014 04:55:49
I wish I had written this when I first saw it, I was full of much more righteous anger at that point. 21/5/2014 05:04:47
I know exactly who/what you're talking about; I saw the link on Twitter this morning. Your points about objectivity and money are spot-on. 21/5/2014 05:23:10
I know who it is now as well, thank you Google :P
Ginger Nuts of Horror
21/5/2014 05:27:16
I just noticed that they have ditched the cutesy girlie graphics. They also need to check the definition of what an in-depth interview actually is
Ginger Nuts of Horror
21/5/2014 05:30:12
For the record I don't post all the interviews that get sent to. I have at least twenty interviews sitting in purgatory, mainly because the replies are terrible, one word answers that do the author and my site no favours. That's awful! No one should pay for a review, it sounds fishy...I'm writing a book right now, so it is good to know what sort of sneakiness is out there. Author's are in a bit of a desperate state at the moment and it's really taking advantage of their need for help...I'm also working on an interview right now for FREE lol, I think people should promote what they love and not expect anything back. Great article btw ;) 21/5/2014 07:14:11
Sadly it's a natural result of the explosion of self-publishing, And I say this as a devoted self-publisher. The explosive growth of e-books and the relative ease of publishing have inundated the market with new writers who will easily fall prey to such tactics. When the market's ripe the unscrupulous will reap what benefits they may. Well said! I can't imagine charging for reviews. How can you even try to be objective when you're taking money to review something. I also couldn't agree more about going outside of your chosen genres. If you read everything, you're an authority on nothing. There's no value there.
Vix Kirkpatrick
21/5/2014 15:06:44
am so disgusted with this... i just have no words.... other than disgusted.
"This just smells of the same shit that paying review sites for a review. As soon as money becomes directly involved with a service all sense of objectivity is lost." 22/5/2014 10:35:54
Exploitation is everywhere in life. Only those with integrity can help to stop its rancid infestation of an otherwise happy place. Give 'em Hell, Gingernuts ;-) Comments are closed.
|
Archives
April 2023
|

RSS Feed